Book Review: Extreme Malice

Reviewed by Tomi Alo

A gripping mystery-thriller that lays bare the fractures, fear, and fury ignited by the COVID-19 pandemic

Extreme Malice takes readers into the heart of today’s culture war. Set against the backdrop of a divided society and the COVID pandemic, the novel follows Amy Wilson, a local school board member whose commitment to her community turns into a fight for survival. 

Four years ago, when Amy ran for Mesa County’s school board, she expected her days to be filled with making budget cuts and reviewing the curriculum, not performing a political tightrope walk for people who view mandatory masks and necessary safety precautions as a hinge on their freedom rights. The once-simple routine turns to a battleground that gives way to threats, protests, and vandalism with her as the main target.

As these anonymous threats and harassment escalate to physical danger, Amy’s retired detective uncle, Jack, springs into action to uncover a shadowy network working against her and aggravating the chaos in Mesa Vista. In the meantime, however, Amy must decide whether her principles and commitment to the safety of the public are worth putting her family in harm’s way.

In Extreme Malice, author JT Tierney explores heavy topics such as racism, political issues, and extremism. It shows the emotional impact that the COVID pandemic had on communities like Mesa County and depicts how much of an influence the government policies have on people’s lives. 

In thought-provoking fashion, Tierney draws a stark contrast between past and present responses to public health crises, particularly when it comes to vaccines. About sixty years ago, vaccines were widely accepted as a scientific breakthrough, a symbol of progress that saved countless lives. But during the Covid pandemic, that trust fractured. Uncertainty, misinformation, and political agendas fueled skepticism, which turned what should have been a relief into a divisive issue.

Through Amy, we experience how dangerous these divisive conflicts can become and  consider the toll they have on those caught in the crossfire. The novel strikes a perfect balance of fast-paced action and character tension. As the threats against Amy escalate, each new incident heightens the fear, anxiety, and urgency for her and her family. Tierney’s writing is direct yet immersive. He manages to keep readers engaged without unnecessary fluff. The story is impactful thought multiple points of view, with each perspective adding more insight and depth rather than distraction.

A book of many strong characters, it’s Tom Franklin, Amy’s father, who stole my heart the most. Like his daughter, his tenacity and resilience are inspiring. As a polio survivor, Tom’s story serves as an eye-opener and offers readers a firsthand look at the lasting effects of the polio virus. Through his character, we are not just told about polio; we experience how it shapes a person long after the initial fight is over. His vivid recounting of the disease’s brutal impact on his body and mind, together with his sessions at the post-polio group, gives us an understanding of the silent struggles that many who have had the virus still endure today. Despite everything he has been through, he never loses his warmth and optimism. His quiet strength, wisdom, and unwavering support for Amy make him an endearing character you’re going to remember. 

The most unsettling and intriguing thing about Extreme Malice isn’t the violence or conspiracy theories. It’s how frighteningly plausible it all feels. The way fear spreads, the ease with which misinformation takes hold, and the extreme actions people justify in the name of “protecting” their beliefs isn’t too far from our present-day reality. 

Tierney doesn’t just deliver a thriller in Extreme Malice. He holds up a mirror to society, forcing readers to confront uncomfortable truths and see how quickly reason can be drowned out by fear and anger. Anyone who enjoys political dynamics, mystery thrillers, and suspense should have this on their to-be-read list.

---

Thank you for reading Tomi Alo’s book review of Extreme Malice by Tomi Alo! If you liked what you read, please spend some more time with us at the links below.